User blog comment:RePeat/Community Poll on Message Walls/@comment-18933973-20130624000420/@comment-4845243-20130624140520

Wow, LBB. This is actually amusing. (No offense intended)

So, this is now about "tolerating" message walls, not about considering logical arguments? It seems that you have closed your mind about the matter. Never a good thing to do in a debate.

Talk pages are no better than message walls when considering stalkers. They will look which ever of the two you have. You may entertain the that people don't look at talk pages. But seriously, all they have to do is take a simple look at the diff. It takes one click to see the whole message (jammers or no!). It is not a very serious proposition to say that talk pages afford more privacy. What they seem to have done is convince people that they do.

Also, getting past all this "Watson" nonsense, your argument is seriously flawed. You are capitalizing on one minor part of an discussion I had with someone else. That is very poor argumentation.

And as I already pointed out, your chart is likewise inaccurate.

Now please, give me an exact situation in which it is necessary to have privacy. In such actual situations, chat or other wikis are quite preferable to anything on the wiki. Because nothing is private, and talk pages are extremely easy to look at.