Board Thread:Community Voting/@comment-5111283-20151015033647

Just wondering how the community feels about how strict we should be in what Support and Oppose reasons are allowed. Should we allow reasons like "would make a good X" or "wouldn't do well as X", or should the reasons be more defined, e.g. "X user would make a great Y because he/she does well in Z situation."?

A) Yes, we should be more strict on Opposes/Supports we allow as 'accepatble'

B) No, we shouldn't be more strict, as long as it's a reason it's good enough.

C) Other. 