Board Thread:Community Discussions/@comment-24718406-20150721001230/@comment-24718406-20150721223547

TheShadowAssassin wrote: FortressOfNight wrote:

TheShadowAssassin wrote:

FortressOfNight wrote:

TheShadowAssassin wrote: I believe that there should be an edit requirement for Chat Moderator. I also believe that it should be raised to 100 edits, with 50 of those being mainspace. I think, personally, that if you have ~100 edits on the wiki, then that shows that you can connect with the community outside of chat and that you have a higher level of dedication towards improving the wiki as a whole. The edit requirement will also help to deter less-dedicated users from requesting Chat Moderator, therefore resulting in fewer crappy chat moderators (which is good for those who feel as if we have too many moderators in general). I can't argue too much against 100 edits generally, since it could help you know the community more, but half of them mainspace? Why? That's absolutely unrelated to chat, even more than a general edit requirement. As noted earlier on in the thread, there's a 2 month requirement already, and unless you're blind and stupid you'll end up figuring out there's a non-chat part of the wiki and likely look around it anyway, if not edit. Luna was totally capable of being a moderator, was familiar with the community, but needed to get 75 edits to put up here RFR, which she did in a legitimately way, but people were neutraling/opposing her first RFR because they thought she spammed her way there. Regardless of whether that's true or not, the edit requirement itself impeded upon her RFR, by no fault of her own. There's no justification for that kind of thing. And if it's 50 mainspace edits, then a good lot of current moderators likely wouldn't meet that. I don't understand why you'd want that? Anybody can easily spam 100 edits on a wall, forum, blogs, etc. That doesn't prove dedication. With 50 mainspace edits, like I said, it will help to deter less-dedicated moderators. Thank you for ignoring the part where that's completely irrelevant. There is no need for a chat moderator to have mainspace edits. Patrollers and rollbacks needs that. Chat moderators are as distanced from articles as you can get. There is no need for it. Think of it this way: I just join the wiki and do nothing but chat for two months, then request Chat Moderator rights. I meet the requirements so I get the rights. I did literally nothing to achieve the rights, and now that I have them I can do whatever the heck I want with them.

Now look at it this way: I join the wiki, and prove myself a dedicated and valued community member by making 100 edits (50 of which mainspace) over a two month period. I had to work for the rights, therefore there is a higher level of dedication. The 50 mainspace edits are there to ensure that I am making quality edits, rather than spamming on walls, forums, etc. to get 100 edits. If you did nothing no one would vote for you...