Board Thread:Community Discussions/@comment-4257955-20150320005751/@comment-25995065-20150320185754

Alemas2005 wrote: Bourgeoisie wrote:

Alemas2005 wrote:

Bourgeoisie wrote:

Alemas2005 wrote:

Bourgeoisie wrote:

Alemas2005 wrote: ...how about petitions? I've got two ideas for that:
 * 1) Keep them where they are, and only move them to here after the petition passes, but the finer details of the petition need to be discussed.
 * 2) Move them here.

The only problem with option 2 in my opinion is that it will have a less organized discussion that way. Option 1 has more organization and will be easier to follow and make decisions. Meiko, under the current petition rules, after a petition has got around 20 signatures, us admins would have to discuss and approve/reject it. Given we have moved "admin discussions" here, I'd like to know whether we'll have to discuss petitions here, under the viewership of everyone, or in admin chat. Seeing as it's something the community will have already thoroughly discussed and been in-the-know about, I don't see why there needs to be some private discussion following a petition. ...so you are saying our own "internal" admin votes should be viewable to all anyway?

Will everyone be able to "have their say" as well? I was saying I don't see any need for petitions to be discussed among admins after the community already discussed it thoroughly. But that's the whole point of our petition system. Here's something to refresh your mind about the rules. That's also really old. Things have changed, and I don't think the private admin discussion following the petition is really necessary. Since the petition gets discussed by the whole community already, there's no real need to talk about it privately among admins afterwards.