User blog comment:Ireithien/This Is a Serious Question./@comment-5510093-20150815163637

Well, I can't really give any real advice without knowing your face shape/structure/hair type (u havent posted a selfie), but I voted Renner because he has a more realistic face shape (only one in a million guys have a jawbone as defined as Colton's). Also I completely echo everything Riolu said about the product and how it is styled being the main difference here, while adding that Renner has super super straight hair, and Colton has a teeny bit of wave, so depending what you have it'll look different.