Board Thread:Community Voting/@comment-5643582-20150926061833/@comment-5369341-20150927202750

ZXSpidermanXZ wrote:

Michaelyoda wrote:

ZXSpidermanXZ wrote:

Michaelyoda wrote: Support all.

Why is this even a thing? And since 51% support means a CM keeps their rights, and 49% means they lose it, what happens if there's only 50% support? It's a community vote. If by some small chance it is 50 percent we'll have to wait until it's not to end the vote. :P Just not making sense to me that we're voting to demote people whom we've had no significant (demotion worthy) issues with having CM. We're almost as inefficient as the government. It's not voting to demote them though. The community never had a say in these people. So they're getting a say now. It's to make sure they have community support. If they don't then they get demoted, but most likely no one will be demoted.

So does this mean all our votes should have a "valid reason," as this is basically a RfR without the Request part? Or is this just a popularity contest?