User blog comment:Alemas2005/Administrator Performance Ratings - Two Years-2 months Later (with non-RfA Admins)/@comment-25461348-20160220034104

A) Alemas2005 Four - Good, maybe even great, but not excellent. 2 votes Basically what everyone else has been saying, being a bit less intimidating would be good.

B) Eagleeyedan Four - Good, maybe even great, but not excellent. Only thing is activity, but he's great otherwise. c=

C) Goggles99 Four - Good, maybe even great, but not excellent. Again, great admin, when he's around.

D) Jdude420 Five - Excellent, top notch.

E) Loney 97 Five - Excellent, top notch.

F) Madkatmaximus Three - Not particularly good, not particularly bad. To be honest, I haven't seen Madkat moderate chat or act like an admin for a long time.

G) MeltE2 Three - Not particularly good, not particularly bad. Haven't really seen Melt do much admin-type stuff, but I think the behind-the-scenes stuff is more what he does. So that makes it hard to judge.

H) Riolu777 Five - Excellent, top notch.

I) ZXSpidermanXZ Four - Good, maybe even great, but not excellent. I would like to see a bit more confidence in chat. That's all.

As far as who does it the best... Tough choice. Probably Jdude.